A Different View of Ecce Homo

by Patrick Werick February 26, 2010 1 Comment

We've found this image (Ecce Homo – Behold the Man) to be helpful for meditation on the Passion.

One of the reasons it is such an aid is because it leaves much for the imagination. Specifically, we don't see the faces of Jesus or Pilate from the front (as is usually the case in Catholic art). Instead, we have a view from the rear of the scene, as if from the perspective of a roman servant.

What pulls the eye in right away, of course, is the central scene of Pilate displaying Jesus Christ to the Jews and saying 'Behold the Man'. Even if the title of this painting wasn't "Ecce Homo," it's still simple to derive that this is indeed the moment the painting captures. Notice the motion of Pilate's arm, pointing towards Jesus Christ, the crown of thorns barely visible on Christ's head, and the exposed back indicating the recent flagellation.

When the eye wanders more through the art painting, it will notice the most visible face in the entire image: that of the woman on the right. The look of anguish on her face, her outstretched arm embracing her friend (or servant perhaps) for emotional support—all indicate that this figure would be none other than the wife of Pontius Pilate.

"And as he (Pontius Pilate) was sitting in the place of judgment, his wife sent to him, saying: Have thou nothing to do with that just man; for I have suffered many things this day in a dream because of him." Matt 27:19

If it was her explicit wish for her husband to have nothing to do with a just man, then her emotional pain displayed in the picture makes perfect sense. The moment Pilate begins to announce that he has tortured the Christ, her heart sinks as the realization truly sets in that her husband displayed cruelty to the just man, despite her warnings. She turns from his side and begins slowly withdrawing—the moment captured in this art painting.

We can relate to the agony of Pilate's wife by inserting how our own sins have caused the suffering of Jesus Christ. The brilliance of the perspective of Pilate's wife is that she, apparently, had no idea that Jesus was God or that He was dying for ours sins. If she had so much sorrow simply because she sensed that something was awry and unjust, imagine how great her sorrow could have been had she known the sublime and grim reality of what was happening before her eyes.

 

Title: Ecce Homo (Behold the Man)   |   Artist: Antonio Ciseri 




Patrick Werick
Patrick Werick

Author


1 Response

Joe Keck
Joe Keck

October 15, 2019

I pretty much agree with your analysis. Even, possibly, Pilate’s wife had her hand on her servant’s shoulder to steady her, so great was her distress. In those days many pagans, as I assume the woman was, believed strongly in dreams and the veracity and import they carry.

This painting has always been a facination to me. It was genius – in my humble opinion – not only for the wife of Pilate and the message she gives tot the viewing audience, but also in in capturing such realism and power. The artist so brilliantly depicted Christ’s humble acceptance of his role as Savior, while showing the governor’s self aggeandised blindness.

I also like the Rembrandt quality, althouh not quite to the older artist’s level, how the work “freezes a mood” of emotional strength in mere oil and canvas. One of my favorite!

joekeck.com

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in Catholic Art Blog

Guido Reni: Expressing Devotion Through Baroque Masterpieces
Guido Reni: Expressing Devotion Through Baroque Masterpieces

by Joe Thomas October 09, 2023

Renowned Italian painter Guido Reni was born in 1575 in Bologna, Italy. Under the tutelage of the Carracci family, he developed his artistic skills and a deep appreciation for classical and Renaissance art.

Continue Reading

Zurbarán's St. Luke before the Crucifix: A Profound Spiritual Encounter
Zurbarán's St. Luke before the Crucifix: A Profound Spiritual Encounter

by Joe Thomas October 09, 2023

"St. Luke before the Crucifix" by Francisco de Zurbarán transcends its status as a mere painting; it is a spiritual odyssey captured on canvas. Zurbarán's mastery of chiaroscuro, coupled with his ability to infuse spirituality into his art, elevates this artwork to the rank of a Baroque masterpiece. It serves as a timeless reminder of art's power to connect us with the divine, inspiring deep contemplation and introspection.

Continue Reading

Exploring the Profound Emotions in
Exploring the Profound Emotions in "St. Peter Grieving" by Carl Heinrich Bloch

by Joe Thomas October 09, 2023

"St. Peter Grieving" is a testament to Bloch's ability to convey emotions through art. The overwhelming sorrow and regret depicted in St. Peter's face resonate with viewers on a profound level. Bloch's portrayal reminds us of the universal human experience of making mistakes, facing the consequences, and grappling with remorse.

Continue Reading